Skip Navigation

Climate Change and Human Health Literature Portal The debt of nations and the distribution of ecological impacts from human activities

Climate Change and Human Health Literature Portal

Srinivasan UT, Carey SP, Hallstein E, Higgins PA, Kerr AC, Koteen LE, Smith AB, Watson R, Harte J, Norgaard RB
2008
Proceedings of The National Academy of Sciences of The United States of America. 105 (5): 1768-1773

As human impacts to the environment accelerate, disparities in the distribution of damages between rich and poor nations mount. Globally, environmental change is dramatically affecting the flow of ecosystem services, but the distribution of ecological damages and their driving forces has not been estimated. Here, we conservatively estimate the environmental costs of human activities over 1961-2000 in six major categories (climate change, stratospheric ozone depletion, agricultural intensification and expansion, deforestation, overfishing, and mangrove conversion), quantitatively connecting costs borne by poor, middle-income, and rich nations to specific activities by each of these groups. Adjusting impact valuations for different standards of living across the groups as commonly practiced, we find striking imbalances. Climate change and ozone depletion impacts predicted for low-income nations have been overwhelmingly driven by emissions from the other two groups, a pattern also observed for overfishing damages indirectly driven by the consumption of fishery products. Indeed, through disproportionate emissions of greenhouse gases alone, the rich group may have imposed climate damages on the poor group greater than the latter's current foreign debt. Our analysis provides prima facie evidence for an uneven distribution pattern of damages across income groups. Moreover, our estimates of each group's share in various damaging activities are independent from controversies in environmental valuation methods. In a world increasingly connected ecologically and economically, our analysis is thus an early step toward reframing issues of environmental responsibility, development, and globalization in accordance with ecological costs.

Expand Abstract

Resource Description

    Ecosystem Change, Extreme Weather-Related Event or Disaster, Food Security, Human Conflict/Displacement, Temperature
    • Ecosystem Change, Extreme Weather-Related Event or Disaster, Food Security, Human Conflict/Displacement, Temperature: Crop/Plant Food Security, Livestock/Game Food Security
    • Ecosystem Change, Extreme Weather-Related Event or Disaster, Food Security, Human Conflict/Displacement, Temperature: Heat
    General Geographic Feature
    Global or Unspecified Location
    Infectious Disease
    Cost/Economic Impact Prediction, Outcome Change Prediction
    Long-Term (>10 years)
    Research Article
    Adaptation, Climate Justice/Climate Equity, Mitigation , Sociodemographic Vulnerability, Vulnerable Population
    • Adaptation, Climate Justice/Climate Equity, Mitigation , Sociodemographic Vulnerability, Vulnerable Population: Adaptation Co-Benefit/Co-Harm, Vulnerability Assessment
    • Adaptation, Climate Justice/Climate Equity, Mitigation , Sociodemographic Vulnerability, Vulnerable Population: Mitigation Co-Benefit/Co-Harm
    Special Report on Emissions Scenario (SRES), Other Climate Change Scenario, Specify
Back
to Top