Superfund Research Program
A New USEPA SW-846 Method 4435 for HAH Analysis
View Research Brief as PDF(402KB)
Background: Accurate identification and quantitation of dioxin-like halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons (HAHs) in environmental matrices are critical for site assessment, risk assessment, and environmental monitoring. Although sophisticated cleanup and instrumental analytic procedures are available to separate, identify, and quantitate individual HAHs, these procedures require specialized equipment and are both costly and time-consuming. A US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Superfund Innovative Technology Evaluation (SITE) report states that the gas chromatograph/mass spectrometer (GC/MS) analysis of 209 demonstration samples cost approximately $1100 per sample and took approximately 8 months.
An inexpensive and rapid screening assay capable of detecting and estimating the relative biological/toxic potency of complex mixtures of dioxin-like HAHs in numerous matrices would greatly facilitate exposure and epidemiological analysis and screening for HAHs. With support from the Superfund Basic Research Program, Dr. Michael S. Denison at the University of California, Davis and Dr. George C. Clark of Xenobiotic Detection Systems (XDS), have developed a rapid and inexpensive recombinant cell bioassay system for the detection and relative quantitation of dioxin-like chemicals in sample extracts that is amenable for large scale screening analysis.
In May 2007, the EPA's Office of Solid Waste (OSW) Organic Methods Workgroup formally reviewed and approved the draft Method 4435 for inclusion into Test Methods for Evaluating Solid Waste, Physical/Chemical Methods, also known as SW-846. The XDS-Chemically-Activated Luciferase gene expression cell bioassay system (XDS-CALUX®) for dioxin-like chemicals, will soon be published and will be posted under "new methods" on the SW-846 website.
Advances: Drs. Denison and Clark and their laboratories designed the XDS-CALUX® bioassay on knowledge of the molecular mechanism of toxicity of dioxin-like HAHs.
They used recombinant technology to place the firefly luciferase gene under the control of the Ah Receptor (AhR) and inserted it into a mouse cell line. The bioassay uses the cell line to detect the presence and level of dioxin-like HAHs in a sample as these compounds bind to the AhR, which then localizes in the nucleus of the cell and binds to dioxin responsive elements (DRE) inducing expression of firefly luciferase. The enzymatic activity of luciferase leads to the production of light that is easily measured. Dioxin-like HAHs present in extracts of environmental matrices are determined following sample processing methods. The assay responds in a time-, dose-, and AhR-dependent and chemical-specific manner. The XDS-CALUX® bioassay is sensitive to <1 part per trillion for dioxin/furan and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) analyses. The bioassay is applicable to: biological matrices including blood (whole serum and extracts), breast milk, and tissues extracts; environmental matrices including soil and sediment, ash, and pulp and paper; and food matrices including animal fats (oil and fats), milk and butter, and animal feeds.
Drs. Denison and Clark have been working to fine-tune the assay for nearly 10 years and have made it available to the research and regulatory communities. Accordingly, the use of the patented technology (US patents 5,854,010 and 6,720,431) has been spread throughout the world:
- 1999 - 500 tons of feed contaminated with approximately 50 kg of PCBs and 1 g of dioxins were distributed to animal farms in Belgium. Shortly afterwards the Belgian government licensed the XDS-CALUX® bioassay for the detection of dioxin-like chemicals in order to protect their residents and food supply.
- June 2000 - XDS licensed the Hiyoshi Ecological Services Company (Hiyoshi Corporation of Japan) to use their technology. Since then, Hiyoshi has become an international leader in using the XDS-CALUX® bioassay and has contributed to licensing of this valuable technology to other countries in Taiwan, China, Vietnam, and Laos.
- October 2001 - the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Office of Regulatory Affairs, Arkansas Regional Laboratory signed a licensing agreement to use the XDS-CALUX® bioassay for investigation as a new technology in the detection of dioxin-like compounds.
- August 2002 - the Belgian government's accreditation service certified XDS' patented bioassay technology as a valid and accurate method for screening detection of chlorinated dioxins/dibenzofurans and PCBs. As a result of the certification, the XDS-CALUX® bioassay licensed by the Belgian government is now an accepted method throughout the European Union for the screening detection of dioxins and PCBs in food products, and has been widely used for the analysis of biological and epidemiologic studies.
- January 2005 - the XDS-CALUX® bioassay was selected by the government of Poland as a screening tool for detection of chemical contamination of their feed and food supply.
- May 2005 - XDS was invited to participate in the US EPA's SITE Program. The XDS-CALUX® bioassay was evaluated in the program study and was an outstanding performer.
- September 2005 - the Minister of the Environment, Japan, promulgated a ministerial notification designating the XDS-CALUX® bioassay as a concrete simplified method in accordance with the law concerning special measures against dioxins.
- May 2007 - the EPA OSW Organic Methods Workgroup officially approved the XDS-CALUX® bioassay for publication in SW-846.
Significance: The XDS-CALUX® bioassay analyses costs are 40%-70% lower than GC/MS analyses. In the EPA SITE study, the XDS-CALUX® analysis took 1.5 months to analyze 209 samples vs. 8 months for the GC/MS analysis. These substantial savings make XDS-CALUX® an excellent screening tool and give researchers, laboratories, and government agencies the option to reduce the use of expensive GC/MS analyses in conjunction with the XDS-CALUX® results to estimate if dioxin levels are above client-established threshold levels.
The EPA OSW Organic Methods Workgroup, by accepting the method for publication in SW-846, approves the bioassay for use in conducting the evaluations and measurements needed to comply with the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). Because other countries look to the US EPA for approval or validation of methods before they are implemented, the inclusion of XDS-CALUX® in SW-846 is a very important step in getting the technology used throughout the US and world.
Development of the XDS-CALUX® technology was funded in part by Superfund Basic Research Program Grant ES04699, and by NIEHS Small Business Innovation Research Grants ES 08372-01 and ES 08372-03.
For More Information Contact:
To learn more about this research, please refer to the following sources:
- Clark GC, Orelien J, Gordon JD, Chu AC, Chu MD, Denison MS. 2005. Mathematical model predictions of GC/MS data for dioxin contaminated environmental samples using CALUX® by XDS. Organohalogen Compounds 67:50-53.
- Windal I, Denison MS, Birnbaum LS, Van Wouwe N, Baeyens W, Goeyens L. 2005. Chemically activated luciferase gene expression (CALUX) cell bioassay analysis for the estimation of dioxin-like activity: critical parameters of the CALUX procedure that impact assay results. Environ Sci Technol 39(19):7357-7364. PMID:16245802
To receive monthly mailings of the Research Briefs, send your email address to email@example.com.